Superior Service From a Superior Agency

Superior Insurance Group is here to help you find quality insurance solutions.

Contact UsClient Center
Business Insurance

Solutions to help protect your company.

Industry Solutions

Coverage for a variety of industries.

Personal Insurance

Solutions with your lifestyle in mind.

Employee Benefits

Coverage to help your employees.

Welcome to Superior Insurance Group

Learn more about our agency.

Superior Insurance Group, formerly Northway Plum Insurance Agency, is a local independent insurance agency, licensed in all 50 states, with one mission: we protect people and businesses by owning risk and advocating claims.

Insurance can often seem cold and unfriendly, but we’ve been looking to change that since we opened in 1882. When you work with us, we strive to make you feel cared for and not like another number in a spreadsheet. We’ll act as your trusted guides, helping you find coverage to help you meet your needs.

Because we’re independent, we work with a variety of top-rated carriers. That means we can work with you to help you find a mix of price, policy, and service to help you protect what matters most. With our commitment to fast, fair, and friendly, you can trust that you’re working with an agency that has your best interests at heart. Whether you need protection for your business, your family, your home, or more, we can help you.

About Our Agency

  Get Your Insurance Quote

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
  • By submitting your mobile number, you agree to receive periodic text messages from us. Standard messaging rates may apply.

The Advantage of an Independent Agency Working for You

What makes our independent agency different?

Find Out More

We represent multiple insurance companies.

We are by your side every step of the way.

We are licensed in all 50 states.

We offer a wide variety of insurance solutions.

We are there for you in your time of need.

  Get a Quote
  Get in Touch
  Get Service

The Solution to Your Insurance Needs

Providing a variety of business insurance, personal insurance, and employee benefits solutions is what Superior Insurance Group does best.

Get a Quote

Professional Associations

Our professional associations signal a dedication to customer service and helping our clients to the best of our ability.

Partner-Trusted-Choice

Partner-IAOA

Partner-Big-i

Partner-TQA

Real clients. Real reviews. Real coverage.

“Paul and his team are the absolute best. They are professional, thorough, and great to work with. Highly recommend working with Superior!”

– Noah T.

“Superior provides great customer service.”

Andreas & Tracy T.Customer since 2023

“Superior has always been helpful when I have had to contact them ”

John & Suzanne K.Customer since 2022

“It's easy to talk to a person. Staff have been helpful and friendly. ”

Cyndie B.Customer since 2026

“ Very helpful and knowledgable”

Gerald & Joyce R.Customer since 2026

“Superior is always looking out for their customers. I've never had any problems with them. If you have any questions about any insurances they will gladly help you.”

Cindy K.Customer since 2022

“I always tell everyone about Superior Insurance group. I just don’t think people get it or understand that there’s somebody out there that will do the work for you within your best interest for your home and auto”

Mary Ann G.Customer since 2022

“Easy to connect with, friendly helpful people and if they need to get back to you, they do. ”

Patricia K.Customer since 2022

“Quick & courteous service whenever I call. Love how you shop around to find us a better rate too.”

Kerrie & Garth H.Customer since 2022

“Very responsive and always looking out for their customers”

AnonymousCustomer since 2022

“Any time I have a question, my question is answered in a very timely manner and explained in a way that I understand and can explain to my family so we can make informed decisions. This is very much appreciated.”

AnonymousCustomer since 2022

“Because your superior!”

David F.Customer since 2025

“My agent does the search for best value/best cost policy, finds applicable discounts, explains thoroughly the coverage, and provides answers to all my questions. With a fixed income and stellar driving record. I feel I am rewarded with excellent coverage.”

Christine B.Customer since 2024

“Any time I have issue I always get a response back immediately and taken care of in very timely manner. Awesome service ”

Shawn & Sheila C.Customer since 2022

“Always check with several companies to get the lowest cost”

Richard & Susan S.Customer since 2022

“Fast service and helpful .”

Allen H.Customer since 2022

“When we have gone into the Bay City office we are always greeted right away and have gotten the help we needed. ”

Galen & Melinda A.Customer since 2022

“Everyone in your office is knowledgeable and friendly. Every time I call, the person I'm speaking with is great.”

Gina & Anthony V.Customer since 2024

“Amazing team to work with! ”

AnonymousCustomer since 2022

“Josie does a great job in all she does and is always incredibly helpful. ”

AnonymousCustomer since 2022

“Our only claim for a new roof because of a hail storm was taken care of. ”

Robert & Patricia R.Customer since 2004

“I love when I call I talk to an actual person and my issue is resolved quickly”

John & Laurie R.Customer since 2022

“The ease to deal with for my insurance needs”

David M.Customer since 2022

“Price ”

Dorothy G.Customer since 2022

“Everything was great thanks ”

Robert & Sandra N.Customer since 2022

“Took care of my car claim quickly.”

Robert & Patti N.Customer since 2022

“They have always helped me out with great service and friendly too!!”

AnonymousCustomer since 2022

“I like that my agent is always available should I have a question and is looking for ways to save me money without sacrificing coverage”

Cheryl K.Customer since 2022

“Staci brought me over to Superior and the service has been phenomenal each and every step of the way. ”

Adam B.Customer since 2022

“Very easy to work with, and super cost efficient!”

Charles & Alisha B.Customer since 2023

“Always very responsive ”

Chris & Barb H.Customer since 2022

“My request for reinstatement of insurance on my stored vehicle was handled quickly and professionally.”

H. Paul & Susan B.Customer since 2022

“We were involved in a accident one year ago we where treated wonderfully, I was injured and yes it was responsible, the only problem was my rate went up, ”

Edward & Mary M.Customer since 2022

“All went well with the recent change of vehicle. Change before regarding PIP change was difficult. ”

Davud & Darlene H.Customer since 2022

“Quick and friendly response to any question and prompt claim filing the first time we needed it!”

David & Paula P.Customer since 2023

“Excellent customer service ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

Marie A.Customer since 2022

“Katie was amazing!”

Debi & Rogg B.Customer since 2022

“Conversations about the policies are always an open communication of explanation of coverages. ”

AnonymousCustomer since 2022

“I believe the Superior Insurance group team & representatives do a great job and do communicate with me as well.”

David H.Customer since 2022

“Josh Faulk is our agent and is terrific. He really has his customers' best interest at heart!”

A client in AlmaCustomer since 2024

“Kayla has done a great job of communicating with us regarding our insurance accounts, and ensuring that we are getting the best coverage for our personal needs,”

Leonard & Shawn O.Customer since 2022

“YOU ALWAYS TAKE CARE OF OUR NEEDS”

Michael & Constance N.Customer since 2022

“The staff has always been pleasant whenever we’ve had a question or a change to our policy. They are efficient and professional. ”

Ronald & Sarah (Sally) P.Customer since 2022

“Very helpful and friendly, always looking for the lowest price and comparing price making sure it's as good or better coverage than the one you have already.”

AnonymousCustomer since 2022

“Superior is easy to work with! They handle each and every request in a timely manner.”

Vincent & Janet V.Customer since 2022

“You are always looking for the best deals for us .”

James & Jean W.Customer since 2022

“When i have a question about my policies I get an answer right away and if something is change it happens right away.”

Randy & Deborah H.Customer since 2024

”Paul Wiese goes above and beyond to make sure his customers are properly insured with the exact coverage they need. I’d highly recommend Superior Insurance Group.

Angie S.

”If you need someone to walk you through your policy and make sure you have adequate coverage, the folks at Superior Insurance Group are the right people for the job!

Paul D.

Serving Michigan and More

Conveniently located in Bay City, MI, and licensed in all 50 states, we proudly serve clients throughout Michigan and across the country.

Contact Us
What We Offer
  • Our streamlined and efficient process.
  • The same treatment for all commercial lines accounts.
  • Annual reviews for commercial and personal lines accounts.
  • Commercial line checklists.
  • One-on-ones to make sure nothing gets missed.
  • Optional considerations or enhancement coverages.
  • True value, not just price.
Find Out How
Interactive Graphic

Click it. Read it. Cover it.

Get a glimpse of the risks you face and how your insurance can protect what matters most.

Garage/Repair Shop
Commercial General Liability / Garage Liability
Risk Factor

Your repair shop may be susceptible to many risks, such as claims due to bodily injury, property damage, personal injury, and more. For example, if a customer accidentally trips and falls while on the premises of your repair shop, you can become exposed to a potential lawsuit and held financially responsible for any injuries that result from the accident.

Solution

Commercial general liability insurance is an absolute necessity for every repair shop. This type of protection provides broad coverage for premises, operations, completed operations and advertising, and personal injury. It will also pay to defend any covered lawsuit or action regardless of its merit. Coverage can be purchased as a separate policy and can be tailored to your specific needs.

Commercial Property Insurance
Risk Factor

When a gas tank explosion causes an uncontrollable fire, your commercial property and everything within it can suffer a significant loss. This can have a detrimental effect on your repair shop business.

Solution

Commercial property insurance can help protect the property your business owns or leases, including things like equipment, inventory, furniture, and fixtures. Whether you own your building or lease your workspace, commercial property insurance can be purchased separately or can be combined with other necessary coverage to protect your business’ physical assets.

Property of Others - Garagekeepers
Risk Factor

The nature of your business means you’re responsible for valuable cars, trucks, and other automobiles. As a repair shop owner, you’re trusted to safeguard vehicles belonging to others. This responsibility brings with it potential liability of being held financially responsible for property damage caused to these vehicles while in your care, custody, and control.

Solution

You should purchase physical damage coverage, referred to as garagekeepers coverage, designed to help you protect your customers’ property and your business in the event that accidents, injuries, or property damage occurs. This protection covers the costs that arise from unfortunate and unforeseeable events, not bad workmanship, faulty parts, or warranties.

Inland Marine and Equipment Floater
Risk Factor

You’re constantly moving your tools from one area of your repair shop to another, exposing your business to potential loss due to damage or theft. And without your specialized tools and equipment, your repair job may come to a screeching halt.

Solution

You can purchase special equipment insurance designed to protect your tools and equipment on the move. The policy will cover equipment for a variety of losses, including fire, explosion, vandalism, theft, collision with other equipment or objects, and overturning.

Workers' Compensation
Risk Factor

If one of your employees receives an injury or becomes ill due to a work-related occurrence, you are required by law to have the proper coverage in place.

Solution

Workers' compensation protects your employees should a job-related injury or sickness occur during the course of employment. This coverage is required by law and may vary by area, so be sure that you understand your obligations for all physical locations where your business operates in and all physical locations where you hire your employees.

Business Auto Insurance
Risk Factor

As a repair shop owner, you have many exposures associated with your business vehicles–owned or leased. With a fleet of cars, trucks, vans, or other types of vehicles used in the course of business, a single accident can potentially put your business in financial jeopardy.

Solution

Business auto insurance provides coverage for vehicles owned or leased by a repair shop and provides coverage for bodily injury, property damage, and other exposures, and could include comprehensive and collision coverage as well.

Commercial Umbrella / Excess Insurance
Risk Factor

Losses and lawsuits are quite common in the repair shop business, and settlements can be substantial. If your business is found to be responsible for damage or injury, you could be facing a large liability loss that exceeds the basic limits of your standard policy.

Solution

You should consider purchasing a commercial umbrella insurance policy which provides higher limits, typically between $2,000,000 and $10,000,000, and often broadened coverages. Coverage is extended over various policies, including general liability insurance, business auto, and directors and officers liability insurance.

Garage Repair Shop 101

Make sure you cover the unique risks you face with garage repair shop insurance.

  • Click on the hotspots.
  • Discover your risks.
  • Get the right coverage.
Not what you’re looking for?

Find even more interactive graphics for farm insurance, contractor insurance, home insurance, and auto insurance.

Superior Insurance Group - Logo 800

Manage Your Account Now

How can Superior Insurance Group help?

24/7 Client Center

  Contact Superior Insurance Group

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.